Refine Search
Sort by
10410 N Cave Creek Road Unit 1071, Phoenix
$269,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7066822 MLS ⋅ 1,038 SqFt.
Turnkey ground-floor condo offering two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a desirable split floor plan, and no interior steps. Currently operating as a successful short-term rental with more than 10 years of rental history, this property presents an excellent opportunity for an investor, seasonal visitor, second-home buyer, or full-time resident. Rental history is available upon request, and the HOA and CC&Rs permit short-term rentals. The bright, open living area features durable tile and LVP flooring, a cozy fireplace, a dining area for four, and direct access to a private patio with additional seating. The updated kitchen includes granite countertops, updated cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances, including the refrigerator, dishwasher, microwave, and range. A stackable washer and dryer and additional storage are conveniently located near the entry. Each spacious bedroom features its own ensuite bathroom, king-size bed setup, television, generous closet space, and patio access. Both bathrooms include a tub-and-shower combination, single-sink vanity, and ample storage. The two outdoor patio areas provide additional space for dining, entertaining, or enjoying morning coffee and beautiful Arizona evenings. This established, pet-friendly community offers three heated swimming pools, heated spas, tennis, pickleball and basketball court, barbecue areas, outdoor seating, and scenic walking paths. The unit also includes one conveniently located reserved covered parking space, with the community mailboxes nearby. HOA fees include water, sewer, trash, common-area maintenance, and Cox cable service. The property can remain a fully furnished and functional short-term rental, allowing a new owner to begin operating with ease. Furniture, televisions, linens, cookware, and other household essentials are negotiable and may convey through a separate bill of sale. Seller holds an active Arizona real estate license.

10410 N Cave Creek Road Unit 1071, Phoenix

2378 W Jake Haven, Phoenix
$442,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7066627 MLS ⋅ 1,882 SqFt.
*Seller will contribute towards concessions or rate buy down!* This two story property features new carpet, fresh interior paint, and a welcoming atmosphere. At the heart of the home lies a spacious kitchen and a bright dining area, perfect for casual breakfasts or dinners with friends. The upstairs primary suite serves as a sanctuary, featuring its own balcony and a spa inspired bathroom for ultimate relaxation. Guest bedrooms are thoughtfully designed with a convenient Jack and Jill bathroom. The office space offers the perfect setup for working from home or setting up a dedicated craft station. Step outside to a covered patio featuring low maintenance turf, ideal for unwinding in the evening or playing with pets. Enjoy this gated community complete with access to the pool and spa!

2378 W Jake Haven, Phoenix

3033 W Tonopah Drive, Phoenix
$298,400
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7066611 MLS ⋅ 824 SqFt.
This fully remodeled Phoenix residence offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 824 sq. ft. of thoughtfully updated living space. The kitchen features soft-closing slim white oak cabinets with modern hardware, quartz countertops paired with a designer backsplash, new sink and fixtures, a stainless steel appliance package, and LED recessed lighting, while the adjacent dining area is anchored by a custom chandelier for a warm, inviting gathering space. Throughout the home, luxury vinyl plank flooring and new baseboards create a durable, cohesive look, complemented by all-new door hardware, hinges, and stoppers for a clean, updated feel. The primary bathroom has been fully reimagined with new soft-closing cabinetry, quartz countertops, a new vanity light and recessed lighting above the shower modern sink faucet, brand new toilet, and all-new shower tile work installed over Redgard and Kerdi waterproofing systems for lasting moisture protection. Every bedroom and living space includes new ceiling fans, hardwired smoke detectors, and updated switches, outlets, and cover plates for safety and a fresh, modern look. Additional updates include a new hallway light fixture, upgraded thermostat, new washer box and valves in the laundry area, an A/C system service, and fresh interior and exterior paint. New dawn-to-dusk exterior wall lights with built-in photocell sensors provide energy-efficient illumination that adjusts automatically to daylight. A move-in ready home where every detail, from the kitchen to the hardware, has been thoughtfully updated for modern living. Situated just north of the 101 and west of I-17, this location puts everyday favorites like Target, Costco Wholesale, AMC Deer Valley, and Chick-Fil-A within easy reach. It's a convenient spot for commuting around the Valley, with quick access north when it's time to escape the heat. For a full list of home features and updates, please see the home updates document in the documents tab.

3033 W Tonopah Drive, Phoenix

5450 E Deer Valley Drive Unit 3010, Phoenix
$389,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7066559 MLS ⋅ 1,246 SqFt.
Perfect resort-style living in this light & bright, move-in-ready, guard-gated, walkable community where urban-living convenience meets suburban comfort. Enjoy an elevated lifestyle, where literally everything you could want & need is right across the street. A perfect choice for full-time living or as a second home in sunny Arizona. HOA covers incredible resort-level amenities + gas, soft water, sewer/garbage, & peace of mind-worth every dollar for this safe, low-maintenance, lock-and-leave residence. New A/C (2023) with parts and labor maintenance warranty through 2033, including summer/winter annual service calls at no additional charge to the homeowner! New luxury plank vinyl, new carpet in bedrooms, tile in wet areas, fresh paint throughout. Tiled 10' x 8-1/2 patio with ceiling fan. Nicely appointed kitchen with stainless steel appliances & granite countertops. Escape to the large primary bath featuring a tiled shower with new glass shower doors and a soaking tub with a tile surround. Recessed power outlet boxes mid-wall for TVs in the primary bedroom and family room. Washer, dryer & refrigerator are included. With so much to do right in the community, be it soaking up the sun or swimming laps at one of 3 pools (3 spas ), admire the lush landscaping while walking the exercise path, two fitness centers, steam rooms, Billard's room & library, relax in one of the multiple lounging areas, yoga/stretching studio, game room, three common area kitchens, numerous outdoor grills, an extensive calendar of social events, clubs, a community executive board room with state-of-the-art equipment to host meetings, or visit the business center and hop on one of a half dozen computers, not to mention just walking across the street for fun. At this price point, with such incredible amenities, a convenient walkable location, and an easy lifestyle, you cannot beat the value! EV charging stations are on the property, too! Without question, this investment in Toscana offers the best urban lifestyle and location in the greater Phoenix metro area. Act now, make an offer & be living the dream!

5450 E Deer Valley Drive Unit 3010, Phoenix

2140 W Heatherbrae Drive, Phoenix
$1,245,000
16 Beds ⋅ 9 Baths ⋅ 7066520 MLS
The Heatherbrae 9 Portfolio is a prime, cash-flowing nine-unit multifamily property in Midtown Phoenix (85015). Featuring seven 2-bed/1-bath and two 1-bed/1-bath units across three single-story triplexes on a ±25,356 SF corner lot, it offers immediate rental upside and value-add potential. PROPERTY HIGHLIGHTS: - UNIT MIX: Seven 2-bed/1-bath, two 1-bed/1-bath (1963 build). - LAYOUT: Three detached single-story triplexes with private patios. - PARKING: 14 spaces (2 covered) plus on-site laundry. - UTILITIES: Individually metered electricity. LOCATION & TRANSIT: - COMMUTE: 5.5 miles to Downtown Phoenix; 9.4 miles to Sky Harbor Airport. - TRANSIT: Under 1 mile to the Valley Metro Light Rail; instant I-17 access. - NEIGHBORHOOD: Walkable Midtown corridor near arts, dining, and histo

2140 W Heatherbrae Drive, Phoenix

6241 W Highland Avenue, Phoenix
$418,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7065803 MLS ⋅ 1,740 SqFt.
Beautifully remodeled and move-in ready! This spacious Phoenix home features 4 bedrooms PLUS 2 additional bonus rooms currently used as bedrooms that can also serve as offices or flex space. Enjoy fresh interior paint, updated flooring and bathrooms, and a large kitchen with abundant cabinetry and counter space. The backyard retreat features a sparkling pool with wrought-iron fencing, generous entertaining space, and a detached structure with electrical, ideal for a workshop, studio, hobby space or storage. Large gated front area, roundabout parking and wrought-iron security gate. Convenient freeway access. Additional interior rooms are unpermitted. Buyer to verify square footage, permits and intended use.

6241 W Highland Avenue, Phoenix

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 5, Phoenix
$669,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7065754 MLS ⋅ 1,996 SqFt.
Buyer incentives available. Welcome to Clarendon 20 Townhomes, a boutique collection of brand-new luxury homes in the highly sought-after Camelback East neighborhood. Designed with consistent, modern architecture, this spacious 2-bedroom, 2.5 bath with an office/den and loft home offers approximately 1,996 sq. ft. of stylish living space. Enjoy private entries, 10' ceilings, expansive windows, and private balconies off the dining areas. The modern kitchen features quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, peninsula breakfast bar, and a pantry. The upstairs bedrooms include walk-in closets. Each home has direct access to a 2-car garage, blending convenience with elegance. Residents benefit from low-maintenance, HOA-managed landscaping and common areas, while the location provides unmatched access to upscale shopping, dining, and outdoor recreation. Walk to Arcadia Lite restaurants, Biltmore shopping, and the Camelback Corridor, or take quick drives to Downtown Phoenix, Sky Harbor Airport, and Scottsdale. This community perfectly balances sophistication, central convenience, and a vibrant urban lifestyle.

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 5, Phoenix

4007 E Agave Road, Phoenix
$519,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7065608 MLS ⋅ 1,472 SqFt.
The Agave Oasis! Discover this beautifully remodeled & immaculate retreat in Ahwatukee's Mountain Park Ranch! Step outside to your own private resort: a brand-new custom Salt-Water pool surrounded by travertine and premium features, set within a stunning private backyard with high-grade turf, professional landscape lighting, a misting system & LED roofline lighting. Choose the pool or your heated above-ground spa for year-round relaxation. Inside, this gorgeous home lives like new. Vaulted ceilings & abundant natural light pour over a neutral palette & wood-look flooring throughout the open, flowing living space. Enjoy games & movies side-by-side on your two televisions! The spotless kitchen shines with SS appliances, quartz counters, tile backsplash, white shaker cabinets, (READ MORE) ...new designer pendant & cabinet lighting, and an expansive island w/breakfast bar. The main bedroom is a true retreat with two closets and an ensuite boasting dual sinks, while the secondary bedrooms feature brand-new custom closet organizer systems for effortless storage. Additional recent upgrades include a whole-house reverse osmosis & water softener system, a rebuilt & enhanced block wall, new motion-sensor backyard lighting, an oversized master bathroom linen closet, overhead garage storage racks, a new LG washer & dryer with added laundry cabinetry, and a Ring doorbell with indoor & outdoor cameras for peace of mind. Enjoy low-maintenance, move-in-ready living close to Ahwatukee's shopping, dining & recreation. Located in the sought-after Mountain Park Ranch community, residents enjoy access to 3 community centers featuring heated pools, spas, parks, tennis & volleyball courts, and beautiful grassy areas for gathering. From the moment you pull up, this home shows pride of ownership at every turn -- nothing to do here but move in and start enjoying resort-style living. Take your private tour of The Agave Oasis today!

4007 E Agave Road, Phoenix

4407 E Amberwood Drive, Phoenix
$429,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7065524 MLS ⋅ 1,434 SqFt.
The search is finally over! Nestled on a coveted corner lot with N/S exposure, this beautifully updated home features a newer Roof, HVAC, & Windows plus lush desert landscaping, & inviting front patio. Step inside to a serene living room w/ vaulted ceilings, soothing tones, and rich vinyl plank flooring. The eat-in kitchen boasts quartz counters, crisp white cabinetry, brand-new stainless appliances, and a pantry for culinary essentials. Retreat to the primary suite, where sliding doors open to the backyard, a custom walk-in closet awaits, & a spa-like bath with double sinks. Outside, unwind on the covered paver patio with multiple seating areas and turf area for pets. Close to schools, parks, shopping, this gated home will not disappoint. Please press more for a full list of upgrades. New roof: Feb 9, 2016 New AC unit: July 20, 2019 Repaint exterior of home: January 3, 2025 Repaint entire interior of home: May 1, 2020 Remodel both bathrooms: January 24, 2024 New window coverings throughout home: June 7, 2021 New energy efficient Milgard windows: October 26, 2021 New flooring throughout home: Feb 6, 2024 New range, Microwave and refrigerator: August 4, 2026 New Whirlpool dishwasher: March 4, 2024 Replaced garbage disposal: January 4, 2024 New light fixtures & ceiling fans throughout house: March 8, 2024 New landscaping & paver patio and walkway: December 21, 2021 Refinished kitchen cabinets: August 4, 2026 Master Closet from the Container Store: August, 2021 Garage door spring replacement: April 29, 2024

4407 E Amberwood Drive, Phoenix

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 18, Phoenix
$669,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7065353 MLS ⋅ 1,996 SqFt.
BUILDER FINANCING INCENTIVE AVAILABLE! Welcome to Clarendon 20 Townhomes, a boutique collection of 20 brand-new residences in Phoenix's Camelback East village. Built in 2026, this three-level home offers 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a separate office/den, and an upstairs loft across approximately 1,996 sq ft per builder. A private entry opens to 10-foot ceilings, expansive windows, and wood-look plank flooring. The kitchen showcases quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a quartz slab backsplash, a peninsula breakfast bar, and a pantry, finished with white shaker cabinetry and brushed gold fixtures. The dining area opens to a private balcony. The primary suite features a walk-in closet with built-in shelving and a spa-inspired ensuite with a tiled walk-in shower, rain shower head and quartz vanity. Additional highlights include a 2-car garage with direct access, inside laundry, ceiling fans, and a covered patio. Residents enjoy low-maintenance, HOA-managed landscaping and common areas, with Biltmore Fashion Park, the Camelback Corridor, Arcadia, downtown Phoenix, and Sky Harbor all minutes away. Do not miss out on this brand-new home!

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 18, Phoenix

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 4, Phoenix
$712,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7065341 MLS ⋅ 1,996 SqFt.
BUILDER FINANCING INCENTIVE AVAILABLE! Welcome to Clarendon 20 Townhomes, a boutique collection of 20 brand-new residences in Phoenix's Camelback East village. Built in 2026, this three-level home offers 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a separate office/den, and an upstairs loft across approximately 1,996 sq ft per builder. A private entry opens to 10-foot ceilings, expansive windows, and wood-look plank flooring. The kitchen showcases quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a quartz slab backsplash, a peninsula breakfast bar, and a pantry, finished with white shaker cabinetry and brushed gold fixtures. The dining area opens to a private balcony. The primary suite features a walk-in closet with built-in shelving and a spa-inspired ensuite with a tiled walk-in shower, rain shower head, and quartz vanity. Additional highlights include a 2-car garage with direct access, inside laundry, ceiling fans, and a covered patio. Residents enjoy low-maintenance, HOA-managed landscaping and common areas, with Biltmore Fashion Park, the Camelback Corridor, Arcadia, downtown Phoenix, and Sky Harbor all minutes away. Do not miss out on this brand-new home!

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 4, Phoenix

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 19, Phoenix
$669,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7065331 MLS ⋅ 1,996 SqFt.
BUILDER FINANCING INCENTIVE AVAILABLE! Welcome to Clarendon 20 Townhomes, a boutique collection of 20 brand-new residences in Phoenix's Camelback East village. Built in 2026, this three-level home offers 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a separate office/den, and an upstairs loft across approximately 1,996 sq ft per builder. A private entry opens to 10-foot ceilings, expansive windows, and wood-look plank flooring. The kitchen showcases quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a quartz slab backsplash, a peninsula breakfast bar, and a pantry, finished with white shaker cabinetry and brushed gold fixtures. The dining area opens to a private balcony. The primary suite features a walk-in closet with built-in shelving and a spa-inspired ensuite with a tiled walk-in shower, rain shower head, and quartz vanity. Additional highlights include a 2-car garage with direct access, inside laundry, ceiling fans, and a covered patio. Residents enjoy low-maintenance, HOA-managed landscaping and common areas, with Biltmore Fashion Park, the Camelback Corridor, Arcadia, downtown Phoenix, and Sky Harbor all minutes away. Do not miss out on this brand-new home!

2601 E Clarendon Avenue Unit 19, Phoenix

2426 W Horsetail Trail, Phoenix
$760,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 7065096 MLS ⋅ 4,091 SqFt.
Located in the sought-after gated community of Sonoran Foothills, this beautifully remodeled and well-maintained home offers thoughtful updates throughout. The kitchen and all bathrooms were remodeled in 2022, along with updated flooring. Major improvements include two new air conditioning systems in 2021, a new roof in 2024 and a full interior and exterior repaint in 2025. The entertainer's backyard features a sports court added in 2023, creating the perfect space for recreation and gatherings. Sonoran Foothills offers outstanding community amenities including multiple pools, parks and beautifully maintained common areas. With updated finishes, newer mechanical systems and a desirable North Phoenix location, this home is truly move-in ready.

2426 W Horsetail Trail, Phoenix

8117 N 13th Street, Phoenix
$570,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7065077 MLS ⋅ 1,840 SqFt.
PRICE IMPROVEMENT! Welcome to this charming, extensively remodeled 1940 cottage-style home, located in a quiet North Central Phoenix cul-de-sac. This home offers 2+ bedrooms, character-rich architectural details such as a coved 12 foot living room ceiling, real hardwood floors, modern granite kitchen, private backyard and so much more. The kitchen has custom cabinetry with upgraded stainless steel appliances. Bathrooms have been tastefully refinished with classic subway tile accents. A cozy office/den space off the primary bedroom is perfect for work, childs play or even a nursery! Location is everything! This home is minutes away from local neighborhood parks, scenic hiking and biking trails, prime dining along the Camelback corridor and downtown Phoenix. Easy Access to 51, only minutes from Phx Sky Harbor and you also have Easy access to Moon Valley and Scottsdale eateries / entertainment. Immerse yourself in the community vibe, and enjoy this charming home for years to come!

8117 N 13th Street, Phoenix

16825 N 14th Street Unit 72, Phoenix
$394,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7065046 MLS ⋅ 1,589 SqFt.
Fall in love with this adorable two-story townhome in Via Bellezza Condominium! Enter to find a large open floor plan that maximizes space and creates an effortless flow for everyday living and entertaining. Spotless kitchen offers a pantry, stainless steel appliances, mosaic tile backsplash, recessed lighting, abundant cabinets, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, and a center island with a breakfast bar. A powder room is located on the main level for easy accessibility. Sizable primary bedroom continues to delight with plush carpeting, a private bathroom with dual sinks, and a walk-in closet. Venture to the cozy balcony- the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind during relaxing afternoons. PLUS! Take advantage of the wonderful Community amenities. Don't miss out!

16825 N 14th Street Unit 72, Phoenix

1717 E Morten Avenue Unit 64, Phoenix
$659,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7064934 MLS ⋅ 1,883 SqFt.
Modern elegance meets desert adventure at Pointe 16, a premier gated enclave in North Central Phoenix. This highly upgraded, tri-level contemporary corner townhome offers chic, low-maintenance urban living. The main floor features 10' ceilings, sleek 12x24 tile, & an open chef's kitchen with quartz countertops, Mojave Slab cabinetry, premium gas appliances, & a dry bar with wine fridge. Enjoy the spacious Great Room opening to a private balcony. The top floor is a private sanctuary hosting a serene primary suite plus a secondary Junior Master Suite, both with luxurious ensuite baths. Situated on the largest lot in the community, this exclusive residence delivers the ultimate Arizona lifestyle, capped off by breathtaking mountain, sunset, & city light views from the rooftop deck!

1717 E Morten Avenue Unit 64, Phoenix

10618 N 27th Street, Phoenix
$929,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7064777 MLS ⋅ 2,003 SqFt.
Welcome to your fully renovated home nestled in the very desirable Shea Heights. This fantastic home offers 3 bedrooms, Den/office, 2 bathrooms, 2 car garage, 2 RV Gates, and a pool. Discover a no expenses spared thoughtfully renovated designer grade interior with NEW oak cabinets, flooring, quartz countertops, highend appliances, windows, tiled showers, and much more! As you step inside, you'll be greeted by the expansive open floor plan, complemented by a beautiful massive kitchen creating an inviting atmosphere. Step outside to a delightful resort style backyard featuring a sparkling pool, artificial turf, outdoor grill and gazebo and beautiful mountain views making it perfect for entertaining! Dont miss the opportunity to make this delightful turnkey home yours, that checks every box!

10618 N 27th Street, Phoenix

1513 E Sheridan Street, Phoenix
$439,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7064719 MLS ⋅ 1,013 SqFt.
Welcome to this Beautiful Remodeled Home Centrally located just minutes from the Heart of Phoenix. This Home has a New AC installed in July of 2026. The Exterior has New Stucco & Paint. The Interior Boasts Quality Craftsmanship & Refined Finishes featuring SS appliances, Quartz Counters, Subway Tile Backsplash, White Shaker Cabinetry, an Island with a Breakfast Bar. Each Bedroom is Equipped with a Walk-in Closet and a Full bathroom w/Shower & Tub combo. The Custom Designed Backyard Provides Year-Round Enjoyment, Featuring a Paver Patio, a Pergola-Covered Seating area Ideal for Outdoor Dining and Entertaining, Hardwired Landscape Lighting and a Bocce Ball Court. Don't Miss the Opportunity to see this Move-in-Ready Residence near the Coveted Coronado Historic Distr

1513 E Sheridan Street, Phoenix

830 S 15th Avenue, Phoenix
$710,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7064669 MLS
Exceptional investment opportunity in the heart of Phoenix! This unique portfolio includes three separate single-family homes being offered together at one price: 830 S 15th Ave (2 bed/1 bath), leased through 10/31/2026 at $1,838.55 per month; 820 S 15th Ave (1 bed/1 bath), leased through 8/31/2027 at $1,553.07 per month; and 1501 W Hadley St (2 bed/1 bath), leased through 11/30/2026 at $1,636.00 per month. Generating approximately $5,027.62 in monthly gross rental income, this portfolio provides immediate cash flow, built-in stability, and long-term investment potential. Whether you're looking to expand your rental portfolio, or take advantage of a unique house-hacking opportunity - live in one home while collecting income from the other two, this property offers exceptional flexibility and a rare opportunity to own multiple income-producing homes in a rapidly growing area. All three homes have separate electric and gas meters, simplifying utility management. All major remodeling was completed in 2021, with updated finishes throughout, making this a true turnkey investment. Each home features a private fenced yard for added privacy and outdoor enjoyment and includes essential appliances such as a stove, refrigerator, and washer/dryer to support tenant satisfaction and minimize ownership expenses. Perfectly positioned for flexible ownership, multigenerational living, or long-term portfolio growth, these properties are conveniently located near Downtown Phoenix, major freeways, public transportation, employment centers, shopping, dining, and entertainment, benefiting from strong rental demand and excellent accessibility. DRIVE-BY ONLY -- please do not disturb tenants. Walkthroughs available with accepted offers only. Act quickly--opportunities like this do not come around often. Buyer to verify all facts and figures.

830 S 15th Avenue, Phoenix

Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.